Answer framework · PSIR Paper I
Constitutional morality in the Indian Constitution
“Constitutional morality in the Indian Constitution”
The platform’s own guidance for planning an answer. It is not an official or model answer.
01What the question asks
A heading under the stem 'Write approximately 150 words on each one of the following' asks for a short analytical note: what constitutional morality means, where the idea comes from, how it works in Indian constitutional practice and why it is contested.
The phrase does not appear in the text of the Constitution, so the note has to explain how a concept outside the text came to matter. The trap is to collapse two senses into one: Ambedkar's sense of a cultivated respect for constitutional forms among those who hold power, and the Supreme Court's recent sense of constitutional values that override prevailing social morality. A good note separates them and takes a view on each.
02The approach
Begin with the source. In the Constituent Assembly on 4 November 1948 Ambedkar took the phrase from the historian George Grote and added his own warning: "Constitutional morality is not a natural sentiment. It has to be cultivated." He used it to justify writing details of administration into the Constitution, arguing that a constitution can be perverted without changing its form, merely by changing the form of administration.
Then trace the idea's judicial career: the Delhi High Court's contrast between constitutional and popular morality in Naz Foundation (2009), its use as a restraint on power in Manoj Narula (2014), and its use to test laws and social practices in Navtej Singh Johar and Sabarimala (both 2018). End with the critique and a judgement.
03Competing viewpoints
The institutional sense (Ambedkar)
Constitutional morality is the habit of respecting constitutional forms: rulers accept limits, oppositions accept defeat, and both act through the procedures the Constitution sets. Ambedkar feared that India lacked the habit, calling democracy a top-dressing on a soil that was essentially undemocratic, and so wrote details of administration into the text to make quiet perversion harder. On this view the idea concerns the conduct of those who hold power.
The transformative sense (the Supreme Court)
The Court has read constitutional morality as the Constitution's own values of dignity, equality, liberty and fraternity, against which laws and social practices are measured. In Navtej Singh Johar the standard was constitutional morality, not popular morality, and Section 377 was read down; in Sabarimala majority opinions invoked it against the exclusion of women from a temple. Scholars such as Gautam Bhatia defend this as faithful to a Constitution meant to transform an unequal society.
The critical view
Critics argue that the term is indeterminate and lets judges substitute their own morality for the legislature's or for a religious community's self-understanding. Dissenting in Sabarimala, Justice Indu Malhotra held that courts should not test religious practices for rationality and that equality cannot override deeply held belief in matters of worship. Others argue that Ambedkar meant restraint by rulers, not a licence for judicial review of social practice.
04Structure
- 1
Introduction (about 30 words)
Define the term and give its source: Grote, quoted by Ambedkar on 4 November 1948, on a cultivated respect for constitutional forms. Note that the phrase is not in the constitutional text.
- 2
Two senses (about 70 words)
Ambedkar's institutional sense and why it explains the Constitution's length and detail; the Court's transformative sense in Navtej and Sabarimala; its use against power in Manoj Narula.
- 3
Critique (about 30 words)
Indeterminacy and judicial subjectivity; Justice Malhotra's dissent; the charge that the judicial sense departs from Ambedkar's.
- 4
Conclusion (about 20 words)
Constitutional morality is the culture a constitution needs: firmest when it restrains power, most contestable when it judges belief.
05Evidence and examples
- Constituent Assembly, 4 November 1948: Ambedkar, citing George Grote, warns that constitutional morality has to be cultivated.
- Naz Foundation v. Government of NCT of Delhi (Delhi High Court, 2009): constitutional morality set against popular morality in the challenge to Section 377.
- Manoj Narula v. Union of India (2014): the Court declined to bar ministers facing criminal charges but said that constitutional morality and good governance should guide the Prime Minister's choice.
- Navtej Singh Johar v. Union of India (2018): constitutional morality, not popular morality, as the standard; Section 377 read down.
- Indian Young Lawyers Association v. State of Kerala (Sabarimala, 2018): constitutional morality invoked by the majority, and Justice Indu Malhotra's dissent on religious autonomy.
Counterarguments
The doctrine's critics make three points. It is indeterminate: the Constitution's values conflict, and the phrase does not tell a judge how to rank them. It is counter-majoritarian in a strong form, letting courts set aside laws on grounds that are not textual. And it may misread Ambedkar, whose concern was the conduct of political actors rather than the review of social practice. Defenders reply that Part III already commits the courts to protect individuals against majorities, and constitutional morality only names that commitment.
Evaluation
Both senses rest on the same premise: a constitution survives only if those who hold power internalise its limits. In the institutional sense the idea is uncontroversial and pressing, given recurring disputes over Governors and assent to Bills, ordinances and defections. In the transformative sense it is strongest where it protects rights expressly guaranteed in Part III, as in Navtej, and most open to challenge where it is used to judge the essentials of a religious practice.
Conclusion
Constitutional morality is the culture the text presupposes. It is best used to restrain power and used with care when it overrides belief.
An illustrative answer
Show an illustrative answer written for this platform
Written to show the framework in use. It is one way to answer, not the answer, and it is not an official or model answer.
Constitutional morality is the habit of respecting a constitution's forms and values beyond its letter. Ambedkar, citing George Grote, told the Constituent Assembly on 4 November 1948 that "constitutional morality is not a natural sentiment. It has to be cultivated." Fearing that it was weak in India, he defended writing administrative detail into the Constitution.
The phrase is not in the text, but the Supreme Court has made it a standard of review. It treated constitutional, not popular, morality as the test in Navtej Singh Johar (2018), invoked it against the exclusion of women in Sabarimala (2018), and relied on it in Manoj Narula (2014) to guide the Prime Minister's choice of ministers.
Critics call the doctrine indeterminate, and Justice Indu Malhotra's Sabarimala dissent held that courts should not test religious practices for rationality. The idea is most secure as a restraint on power and most contestable when it judges belief.
Sources
- 01Granville Austin, The Indian Constitution: Cornerstone of a Nation
- 02Gautam Bhatia, The Transformative Constitution: A Radical Biography in Nine Acts
- 03Madhav Khosla, India's Founding Moment: The Constitution of a Most Surprising Democracy
- 04George Grote, A History of Greece