Skip to content

Paper I · Part B · Unit 2

Making of the Indian Constitution

What the founders inherited from colonial rule, what they rejected, and how rival visions of society and state were negotiated into one document.

Official syllabus

Making of the Indian Constitution: Legacies of the British rule; different social and political perspectives.

What the unit asks

The unit asks two questions about the founding. First, what did the Constitution inherit from British rule (institutions, laws, administrative habits and the Government of India Act, 1935) and how far did it transform that inheritance? Second, which social and political perspectives contended in the Constituent Assembly, and how were they reconciled or overruled?

The examiner wants more than a list of sources. A strong answer argues about continuity and rupture, uses the Constituent Assembly Debates as evidence, and draws on the scholarship that interprets the founding — Granville Austin's account of consensus and accommodation, and more recent work by Madhav Khosla and Rohit De. Detailed institutional history is on the platform's polity pages, especially The Constituent Assembly and the Making of the Constitution and Historical Background of the Constitution.

01The Constituent Assembly

The demand for a constituent assembly was voiced by M. N. Roy in 1934 and adopted by the Congress soon after. Under the Cabinet Mission Plan of 1946, members were elected indirectly by the provincial legislatures, themselves chosen on a limited franchise, with seats also allotted to the princely states. The Assembly first met on 9 December 1946; Nehru's Objectives Resolution of 13 December, adopted in January 1947, set out its aims. The Muslim League's boycott and Partition reshaped it.

The Drafting Committee, chaired by Ambedkar from August 1947, worked from a draft prepared by the constitutional adviser B. N. Rau. The Constitution was adopted on 26 November 1949 and came into force on 26 January 1950. Critics questioned the Assembly's representativeness; Granville Austin answered that the Congress was itself a broad coalition, and that the Assembly deliberately included non-Congress figures such as Ambedkar, and decided by consensus and accommodation rather than bare majorities.

02Institutional legacies of British rule

The largest single source of the Constitution's text was the Government of India Act, 1935: its federal scheme and three legislative lists, the office of Governor, emergency provisions, public service commissions and a federal court. The power of the Union to take over a state's government (Article 356) descends from section 93 of the 1935 Act. Earlier reforms left other traces: legislative councils from 1861, the separate electorates of 1909 and the dyarchy and bicameral central legislature of 1919.

The founders also inherited a Westminster model of parliamentary government, the common law and its codes, an integrated judiciary, and the all-India civil services, which Sardar Patel defended in the Assembly as indispensable to unity. The colonial state's centralism and preventive detention laws survived in modified form. See Sources of the Constitution and Historical Background of the Constitution.

03Continuity and transformation

Was the Constitution the 1935 Act with a preamble? The continuity thesis points to the reproduced provisions, the bureaucratic and emergency powers, and colonial laws that remained in force: sedition, for example, survived in the Indian Penal Code until the code was replaced by the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita in 2024.

The transformation thesis is stronger. The Constitution added universal adult franchise, which no colonial reform contemplated; justiciable fundamental rights, prefigured in the Nehru Report (1928) and the Karachi Resolution (1931) rather than in British practice; the abolition of untouchability; a republic; and Directive Principles committing the state to social and economic justice. Austin called the Constitution first and foremost a social document, aimed at a social revolution. Madhav Khosla's India's Founding Moment (2020) argues that the founders consciously used codification, centralisation and representation to create democratic citizens in a society without democratic traditions.

04Political perspectives in the Assembly

Several political visions contended. The dominant Nehruvian vision joined liberal democracy to planning and social reform, expressed in the Objectives Resolution. The Gandhian vision of a decentralised polity built on village republics, set out in Shriman Narayan Agarwal's Gandhian Constitution for Free India (1946), lost: Ambedkar dismissed the village as a site of localism and caste, and the Gandhian position was accommodated only in the Directive Principles (Article 40 on panchayats) and later in the 73rd Amendment. See Gandhi and Ambedkar.

A socialist current, voiced by K. T. Shah, sought to declare India 'secular, federal, socialist' — rejected in 1948 and partly adopted by the 42nd Amendment in 1976. Hindu traditionalists pressed for cow protection (Article 48) and Hindi. Federalists lost ground to centralists after Partition, producing a strong Union. Property rights (Article 31) and official language (the Munshi–Ayyangar formula in Part XVII) were settled by hard-fought compromises.

05Social perspectives: caste, religion, tribe, gender

The Assembly reconciled competing claims of social groups. Caste: the Poona Pact settlement became reserved seats for Scheduled Castes in joint electorates, and Article 17 abolished untouchability. Religion: the Advisory Committee on minorities, chaired by Patel, recommended dropping reserved seats for religious minorities after Partition, a decision several minority members accepted; cultural and educational rights (Articles 29 and 30) and freedom of religion (Article 25) remained, and a uniform civil code was left as a directive (Article 44).

Tribal representatives such as Jaipal Singh pressed the claims of adivasis, reflected in the Fifth and Sixth Schedules. Fifteen women sat in the Assembly (among them Hansa Mehta, Durgabai Deshmukh and Rajkumari Amrit Kaur) and the Constitution adopted universal adult franchise without a gender qualification. Ambedkar's resignation in 1951 was partly over the stalled Hindu Code Bill, a sign of how far social reform lagged behind political equality.

06Interpreting the founding

Granville Austin's The Indian Constitution: Cornerstone of a Nation (1966) remains the classic account: the Constitution as a social revolution pursued through national unity and democracy, framed by a leadership committed to consensus. Critics from the left saw an elite settlement that protected property; Gandhians lamented a Westminster import — one member complained that they had wanted the music of the veena or sitar and got an English band; Hindu nationalists objected to its secular and Western character.

Newer scholarship shifts the focus. Rohit De's A People's Constitution (2018) shows ordinary citizens using the new rights in courts from the first years, making the Constitution a living document from below. Ambedkar's closing speech of 25 November 1949 framed the enduring problem: India was entering a life of contradictions, with equality in politics and inequality in social and economic life. See Salient Features of the Indian Constitution.

Debates

Was the Constituent Assembly representative?

Critics note indirect election on a limited franchise, Congress dominance and the absence of the Muslim League after Partition. Defenders reply that the Assembly included most shades of opinion, that the Congress was itself a coalition, and that the first general election (1951–52) under the Constitution gave it retrospective popular endorsement. The quality of deliberation, recorded in the Debates, is the strongest argument for its legitimacy.

Did the founders choose the right relationship between state and society?

Ambedkar and the centralists believed a strong, reforming state was needed to dismantle caste and build a nation. Gandhians and some federalists argued that this produced a top-heavy state distant from village India. Seventy-five years on, the 73rd and 74th Amendments, coalition federalism and the growth of judicial review suggest the settlement has been continually renegotiated.

Answer strategy

Organise around continuity and change. For legacies, separate institutional (1935 Act, Westminster, civil services, law) from ideological (liberal constitutionalism, the Nehru Report and Karachi Resolution) and social (communal categories, princely states, Partition). For perspectives, name the positions, their spokesmen and the compromise reached — village or individual, centre or states, secularism, property, language.

Quote the Constituent Assembly Debates only where certain; paraphrase otherwise. Use Austin, Khosla and De to frame the argument. Common errors: attributing the Constitution to Ambedkar alone, treating the 1935 Act as the whole story, and omitting the social groups whose claims shaped the text.

Readings

  • Granville Austin, The Indian Constitution: Cornerstone of a Nation
  • Granville Austin, Working a Democratic Constitution: The Indian Experience
  • B. Shiva Rao (ed.), The Framing of India's Constitution
  • Madhav Khosla, India's Founding Moment: The Constitution of a Most Surprising Democracy
  • Rohit De, A People's Constitution: The Everyday Life of Law in the Indian Republic
  • Bipan Chandra and others, India's Struggle for Independence

In the UPSC papers

Asked by UPSC

1 question · 2024

  1. 2024 · PSIR I · Q5(b) · 10 marks

    Objective Resolution of the Constituent Assembly

Verbatim from the official UPSC Main papers, linked to Making of the Indian Constitution in the PYQ dataset.PYQ Intelligence →

Practice questions

  1. Q1PSIR style15 marks· 200 words

    'The Constitution of India is the Government of India Act, 1935 with a preamble.' Critically examine.

    How to approach it

    Provisions inherited; universal franchise, rights, republic and Directive Principles as ruptures; Austin's social revolution; conclusion on transformation.

  2. Q2PSIR style15 marks· 200 words

    Examine the role of consensus and accommodation in the making of the Indian Constitution.

    How to approach it

    Austin's argument; examples of language, property and minorities; limits of consensus (the Gandhian defeat, Ambedkar's dissatisfaction on social reform).

  3. Q3PSIR style10 marks· 150 words

    How were Gandhian ideas accommodated in the Indian Constitution?

    How to approach it

    Agarwal's Gandhian constitution; Ambedkar's rejection; Articles 40, 43, 47, 48; the 73rd Amendment as later vindication.

  4. Q4PSIR style20 marks· 250 words

    Discuss the different social perspectives on minority rights in the Constituent Assembly.

    How to approach it

    Separate electorates and their abandonment; Articles 25–30; Scheduled Castes and Tribes; uniform civil code as directive; assessment.

Practice questions are original to this platform and are not previous year questions. For questions actually set by UPSC, see PYQ Intelligence.

Explore further

Sources

  1. 01UPSC, Civil Services Examination Notice: Scheme and Syllabus (Political Science and International Relations) (opens in a new tab). Union Public Service Commission
  2. 02Constituent Assembly Debates (Lok Sabha Secretariat)
  3. 03Government of India Act, 1935
  4. 04Constitution of India (Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice) (opens in a new tab)
  5. 05Granville Austin, The Indian Constitution: Cornerstone of a Nation, 1966