Landmark judgment · 1970
Madhav Rao Scindia (Privy Purses case)
The Court struck down the President's order 'derecognising' all former rulers, holding that the power under Article 366(22) could not be used to abolish privy purses by executive action; Parliament abolished them by amendment the next year.
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Decided
- 15 December 1970
- Bench
- 11-judge Constitution Bench
- Citation
- (1971) 1 SCC 85
01The constitutional issue
At integration, the rulers of the princely States were guaranteed privy purses and personal privileges by covenants and agreements, which Article 291 and Article 362 recognised. In September 1970 a constitutional amendment bill to abolish them passed the Lok Sabha but fell short of the required majority in the Rajya Sabha by a fraction of a vote. The President then issued orders under Article 366(22), which defined a "Ruler" as the person recognised by the President, withdrawing recognition from all rulers at once. The rulers challenged the orders.
02The decision
By a majority, with Hidayatullah CJ and Shah J writing the principal opinions, the Court held the orders invalid. The power to recognise a ruler, and to recognise a successor, did not include a power to derecognise the whole order of rulers in order to end the privy purses — an end Parliament had just failed to achieve by amendment. Using the definition clause for that purpose was an abuse of power. The rulers' entitlements under Article 291 were enforceable legal rights, and the bar in Article 363 on disputes arising from the covenants did not shut out a challenge to the orders themselves.
03Significance
The decision checked an attempt to achieve by executive action what the amending procedure had refused. Politically it was short-lived: the Lok Sabha was dissolved weeks later, and the 1971 election, fought partly on the Court's decisions in this case and in R.C. Cooper, gave the government the majority it needed. The case belongs to the sequence of confrontations that culminated in Kesavananda.
04What happened afterwards
The 26th Amendment (1971) omitted Articles 291 and 362 and inserted Article 363A, ending the recognition of rulers and their privy purses. A Constitution Bench upheld that amendment in Raghunathrao Ganpatrao v. Union of India (1993).
Why it matters for UPSC
Prelims: privy purses; Articles 291, 362 and 366(22); the 26th Amendment (1971) and Article 363A. In Mains, use it in the account of the Parliament–judiciary conflict of 1967–73.
Explore further
Concept
Polity & Governance
Article
- Article 291 · Privy purse sums of Rulers
- Article 362 · Rights and privileges of Rulers of Indian States
- Article 363 · Bar to interference by courts in disputes arising out of certain treaties, agreements, etc.
- Article 363A · Recognition granted to Rulers of Indian States to cease and privy purses to be abolished
- Article 366 · Definitions
Amendment
Judgment
Sources
- 01Supreme Court of India, judgment of 15 December 1970. Supreme Court of India