Landmark judgment · 2024
Sita Soren (Legislators' Bribery case)
A unanimous seven-judge bench overruled P.V. Narasimha Rao (1998), holding that legislators who take bribes to vote or speak enjoy no immunity from prosecution under Articles 105(2) or 194(2).
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Decided
- 4 March 2024
- Bench
- 7-judge Constitution Bench
- Doctrine
- Functional test for legislative privilege
01The constitutional issue
Sita Soren, a member of the Jharkhand Assembly, was charged with taking a bribe to vote for a candidate in the 2012 Rajya Sabha election. She claimed immunity under Article 194(2), relying on P.V. Narasimha Rao v. State (1998), in which a five-judge bench had held, by three to two, that MPs who took bribes and then voted against a no-confidence motion in 1993 were immune because the bribe was linked to their vote — while a member who took a bribe but did not vote was not.
02The decision
Chandrachud CJ, for a unanimous bench, overruled Narasimha Rao. The privilege in Articles 105(2) and 194(2) protects speech and votes in the House, and a claim of immunity must be tied to the collective functioning of the House and necessary to the discharge of a legislator's essential duties. Taking a bribe is neither.
The offence of bribery is complete when the bribe is accepted, whether or not the legislator later votes as agreed. The 1998 majority had produced a paradox — protecting the member who kept his corrupt bargain and exposing the one who did not — which the Court found incompatible with the purpose of privilege. It applied the same reasoning to the Rajya Sabha election vote at issue.
03Significance
The judgment narrowed privilege to what the House needs in order to function, closing a protection that no other parliamentary democracy extends to bribery. Some warned that exposing legislators to prosecution for conduct connected with votes could invite politically motivated cases; the Court's answer was that a privilege for corruption protects no legitimate legislative function.
04What happened afterwards
The decision completes a line running from Keshav Singh and Raja Ram Pal: legislative privilege is real but bounded by the Constitution and by its purpose. Parliament's privileges remain uncodified.
Why it matters for UPSC
Prelims: 4 March 2024; seven judges; unanimous; P.V. Narasimha Rao overruled. In Mains, use it on parliamentary privileges and accountability.
Explore further
Concept
PSIR Optional
Polity & Governance
Article
- Article 105 · Powers, privileges, etc., of the Houses of Parliament and of the members and committees thereof
- Article 194 · Powers, privileges, etc., of the Houses of Legislatures and of the members and committees thereof
- Article 122 · Courts not to inquire into proceedings of Parliament
- Article 212 · Courts not to inquire into proceedings of the Legislature
Judgment
Sources
- 01Supreme Court of India, judgment of 4 March 2024. Supreme Court of India
- 02Sita Soren v. Union of India, 4 March 2024: text of the judgment (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India