Landmark judgment · 2007
Raja Ram Pal (Cash-for-Query case)
By four to one, the Court upheld Parliament's expulsion of eleven members caught taking money to ask questions, holding that the power to expel is part of parliamentary privilege but that its exercise is open to judicial review.
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Decided
- 10 January 2007
- Bench
- 5-judge Constitution Bench
- Citation
- (2007) 3 SCC 184
- Doctrine
- Judicial review of the exercise of parliamentary privilege
01The constitutional issue
In December 2005 a television sting showed ten members of the Lok Sabha and one of the Rajya Sabha accepting money to ask questions in Parliament. On committee reports, both Houses expelled them. The members argued that the Constitution sets out exhaustive grounds for vacating a seat in Articles 101–103, leaving no power of expulsion, and that the expulsions were reviewable.
02The decision
Sabharwal CJ, for the majority, held that the power to expel a member for conduct unbecoming is part of the privileges inherited under Article 105(3) and is necessary for the House to protect its integrity; it is not limited by the provisions on disqualification.
Its exercise, however, is subject to judicial review. Article 122 bars challenges for mere irregularity of procedure, not for illegality or unconstitutionality; the Court may examine gross illegality, irrationality, violation of natural justice and perversity, while according the House due deference. The expulsions were upheld. R.V. Raveendran J dissented, holding that the Constitution's grounds for vacancy were exhaustive.
03Significance
The decision confirmed the principle of Keshav Singh that no House is the final judge of the limits of its own power, while upholding Parliament's capacity to discipline its members. The risk its critics identify is that an uncodified power of expulsion can be used by a majority against opponents; the dissent's preference for the text's exhaustive list answers that risk at the cost of disabling self-regulation.
04What happened afterwards
In December 2023 the Lok Sabha expelled a member on its Ethics Committee's report on allegations of accepting gifts in return for asking questions; the member challenged the expulsion and was re-elected in 2024. Sita Soren (2024) held that bribery is not protected by privilege. Parliament has not codified its privileges.
Why it matters for UPSC
Prelims: 2007; eleven members; Articles 105(3) and 122; Raveendran J's dissent. In Mains, use it on parliamentary privileges, ethics committees and codification.
Explore further
Polity & Governance
Article
- Article 101 · Vacation of seats
- Article 102 · Disqualifications for membership
- Article 103 · Decision on questions as to disqualifications of members
- Article 105 · Powers, privileges, etc., of the Houses of Parliament and of the members and committees thereof
- Article 122 · Courts not to inquire into proceedings of Parliament
- Article 194 · Powers, privileges, etc., of the Houses of Legislatures and of the members and committees thereof
Judgment
Sources
- 01Supreme Court of India, judgment of 10 January 2007. Supreme Court of India