Five-minute module · Institution
The UN Security Council
Why the one body that can bind every state and authorise force is also the hardest institution in world politics to reform: the bargain of 1945 and its consequences.
Step 1 of 5
The bargain of 1945
The League of Nations failed partly because great powers stayed out of it or left it. The authors of the UN Charter drew the opposite lesson: collective security would work only if the powers able to enforce it were inside the system and could not be outvoted by it. The Security Council was the result. Members confer on it "primary responsibility for the maintenance of international peace and security" (Article 24) and agree to carry out its decisions (Article 25). In return, five permanent members, China, France, the Soviet Union (now Russia), the United Kingdom and the United States, received a privilege no other state holds: the veto.
Step 2 of 5
How the veto works
The Council has fifteen members: the five permanent members and ten elected by the General Assembly for two-year terms. It was enlarged from eleven in 1965, the only expansion in its history. Procedural decisions need nine votes; all others need nine votes "including the concurring votes of the permanent members" (Article 27(3)), which is the veto. Practice since the 1940s, accepted by the International Court of Justice in its Namibia opinion of 1971, treats a permanent member's abstention as no bar. Under Chapter VII the Council can determine a threat to the peace, impose sanctions and authorise force, and those decisions bind every member. Under the Charter, force is lawful only in self-defence or with the Council's authorisation.
Step 3 of 5
Effective when the powers agree
The design makes the Council's record depend on agreement among the five. In the Cold War vetoes paralysed it on most security questions; it authorised force in Korea in 1950 only because the Soviet Union was boycotting its meetings. The General Assembly responded with the Uniting for Peace resolution of 3 November 1950, which lets it meet in emergency session when the Council is blocked. When the powers agreed after 1990, the Council was transformed: it authorised the expulsion of Iraq from Kuwait, created tribunals for the former Yugoslavia and Rwanda, multiplied peacekeeping mandates and built counter-terrorism obligations after 2001. When they disagree, as over Syria after 2011 and Ukraine since 2022, it cannot act against a permanent member or its clients.
Step 4 of 5
Why reform is so hard
The Council's membership reflects the power map of 1945. Africa and Latin America have no permanent seat, and neither does India, the most populous state. Reform has been discussed in the General Assembly's Intergovernmental Negotiations since 2009 without agreement on a negotiating text. The obstacle is constitutional: under Article 108 a Charter amendment needs a two-thirds vote of the Assembly and ratification by two-thirds of members, including all five permanent members. Reform therefore requires the consent of those whose privilege it would dilute. The aspirants are divided too: the G4 (Brazil, Germany, India and Japan) seek new permanent seats, the African Union claims two with full rights, and the Uniting for Consensus group, which includes Pakistan, opposes new permanent members.
Step 5 of 5
India and the Council
India has served eight elected terms, most recently in 2021–22, and is a candidate for 2028–29. Its case for a permanent seat rests on population, economic weight, a long record as a major contributor of peacekeepers, and the argument that an unrepresentative Council loses the authority its decisions need. Its experience also shows the Council's double face. Sanctions listings under the 1267 regime give India a channel against terrorist groups based in Pakistan, yet some proposed listings have been delayed by holds placed by a permanent member. The veto that blocks reform is also what makes a permanent seat worth having, which is why the G4 has offered that new permanent members would not use a veto until a later review.
The idea to keep
The Security Council is effective exactly as far as its five permanent members agree, because the veto was the price of their participation in 1945. Article 108 also gives each of them a veto over amendment of the Charter, so reform needs the consent of those whose privilege it would reduce.
Check yourself
Answer each question in your own words first, then open it to compare.
Q1Does an abstention by a permanent member block a resolution?
Answer
No. Article 27(3) speaks of "concurring votes", but consistent practice, accepted by the International Court of Justice in its Namibia opinion (1971), treats abstention as no bar to adoption.
Q2Why does Article 108 make reform so difficult?
Answer
Charter amendments need a two-thirds vote in the General Assembly and ratification by two-thirds of members including all five permanent members, so each of them can block any change to the Council.
Q3What does the Uniting for Peace resolution (1950) allow?
Answer
When the Council fails to act because the permanent members disagree, the General Assembly may meet in emergency special session and recommend collective measures.
These questions are original to this platform; they are not previous year questions.
Read next
Sources
- 01Charter of the United Nations (1945), Articles 23–27, 39–42 and 108 (opens in a new tab). United Nations
- 02General Assembly resolution 377 (V), Uniting for Peace. United Nations, 3 November 1950
- 03International Court of Justice, Legal Consequences for States of the Continued Presence of South Africa in Namibia (South West Africa), Advisory Opinion. International Court of Justice, 21 June 1971
- 04David L. Bosco, Five to Rule Them All: The UN Security Council and the Making of the Modern World (2009). Oxford University Press
- 05India and the United Nations (opens in a new tab). Ministry of External Affairs, Government of India