Skip to content

Landmark judgment · 2018

Jarnail Singh

A Constitution Bench declined to refer M. Nagaraj to a larger bench but held that States need not collect data on the backwardness of Scheduled Castes and Tribes before reserving promotions, while applying the creamy-layer principle to them.

Jarnail Singh v. Lachhmi Narain Gupta
Court
Supreme Court of India
Decided
26 September 2018
Bench
5-judge Constitution Bench
Citation
(2018) 10 SCC 396
Doctrine
Creamy layer in promotions for SCs and STs

01The constitutional issue

The Union and several States asked the Court to revisit M. Nagaraj (2006). They argued that its requirement of quantifiable data on the backwardness of the Scheduled Castes and Tribes contradicted Indra Sawhney, which treated these groups as presumptively backward, and that the creamy-layer principle could not apply to them.

02The decision

R.F. Nariman J, for a unanimous bench, held that Nagaraj need not go to a larger bench but corrected it on one point. Requiring States to show the backwardness of SCs and STs was contrary to Indra Sawhney, since their inclusion in the lists under Articles 341 and 342 reflects their backwardness; that requirement was set aside. The requirements of data on inadequate representation and of attention to administrative efficiency under Article 335 remained.

The Court also held that the creamy-layer principle, as an aspect of equality under Articles 14 and 16, applies to the Scheduled Castes and Tribes in the context of promotions, so that the most advanced among them do not take the benefit meant for others.

03Significance

The judgment eased one of the Nagaraj conditions while extending another principle — the creamy layer — into territory long thought closed to it. Critics argue that caste stigma, not income, is what reservation for SCs and STs addresses, so economic advancement does not end the disadvantage; supporters respond that the benefits have concentrated in a small section of each group.

04What happened afterwards

In 2022 a three-judge bench in the continuing Jarnail Singh litigation held that data on representation must be collected cadre by cadre and reviewed periodically, declining to set a yardstick. In Davinder Singh (2024) four judges of a seven-judge bench, in separate opinions, favoured extending the creamy-layer principle to SC and ST reservation generally; the Union said it would not do so.

Why it matters for UPSC

Prelims: 2018; creamy layer applied to SCs and STs in promotions; no data on backwardness required. In Mains, use it in the sequence Indra Sawhney → Nagaraj → Jarnail Singh → Davinder Singh.

Explore further

Sources

  1. 01Supreme Court of India, judgment of 26 September 2018. Supreme Court of India
  2. 02Jarnail Singh v. Lachhmi Narain Gupta, (2018) 10 SCC 396: text of the judgment (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India