Skip to content

Landmark judgment · 2024

Davinder Singh (SC Sub-classification case)

By six to one, a seven-judge bench held that States may sub-classify the Scheduled Castes to give preference to the more disadvantaged among them, overruling E.V. Chinnaiah (2004); four judges also favoured excluding a creamy layer.

State of Punjab v. Davinder Singh
Court
Supreme Court of India
Decided
1 August 2024
Bench
7-judge Constitution Bench
Doctrine
Sub-classification within reserved categories

01The constitutional issue

Punjab reserved half of its Scheduled Caste quota, as a first preference, for the Balmiki and Mazhabi Sikh communities, most recently by a 2006 Act. The High Court struck the provision down, following E.V. Chinnaiah v. State of Andhra Pradesh (2004), in which five judges held that the castes listed by the President under Article 341 form a single homogeneous class that States cannot divide. In 2020 another five-judge bench doubted Chinnaiah and referred the question to seven.

02The decision

Chandrachud CJ (for himself and Manoj Misra J), with Gavai, Vikram Nath, Pankaj Mithal and Satish Chandra Sharma JJ concurring separately, held that the Scheduled Castes are not a homogeneous class. Article 341 identifies castes for constitutional purposes but does not make them internally uniform, and Articles 14, 15(4) and 16(4) permit sub-classification in pursuit of substantive equality. Chinnaiah was overruled.

Sub-classification must rest on quantifiable, demonstrable data about relative backwardness and representation, is open to judicial review, and cannot reserve the entire quota for one sub-group. Gavai J, with whom three others agreed in substance, said that the State should also identify and exclude a creamy layer among the SCs and STs — a view beyond the questions referred.

Bela M. Trivedi J dissented: the President's list can be altered only by Parliament, and sub-classification by States amounts to altering it.

03Significance

The judgment shifted the focus of reservation from equality between groups to equity within them, responding to evidence that benefits had concentrated among a few castes. It is contested from within the beneficiary communities: the most deprived castes welcomed it, while others feared that division would weaken a common political front and invite manipulation by governments.

04What happened afterwards

The Union government stated in August 2024 that the creamy-layer principle would not be applied to SC and ST reservation. Several States, among them Haryana and Telangana, moved to sub-classify their Scheduled Castes.

Why it matters for UPSC

Prelims: 1 August 2024; 6:1; E.V. Chinnaiah overruled; Trivedi J's dissent. In Mains, use it on social justice within reserved categories and the creamy-layer debate.

Explore further

Sources

  1. 01Supreme Court of India, judgment of 1 August 2024. Supreme Court of India
  2. 02State of Punjab v. Davinder Singh, 1 August 2024: text of the judgment (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India