Skip to content

The Constitution (Eighty-fifth Amendment) Act, 2001

85th Amendment (2001)

The amendment that added consequential seniority to reservation in promotion for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, with retrospective effect from 1995.

01Context

After the Seventy-seventh Amendment restored reservation in promotion, the Supreme Court held in a series of cases, beginning with Union of India v. Virpal Singh Chauhan (1995) and Ajit Singh Januja (1996), that a reserved candidate promoted earlier because of the quota did not thereby gain seniority over general candidates who were senior in the lower grade: when the general candidate was later promoted, he regained his seniority, a rule known as the catch-up principle. The government responded by amending article 16(4A).

02What it changed

  • Article 16(4A) amended so that reservation in promotion for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes is "with consequential seniority".
  • The amendment given effect retrospectively from 17 June 1995, the date on which the Seventy-seventh Amendment came into force.

03Political and constitutional significance

The amendment overrode the catch-up rule and ensured that reserved candidates promoted earlier keep the seniority that comes with promotion. Its supporters argued that without it reservation in promotion would be hollow, since quota beneficiaries would be pushed back down the seniority list. Its critics argued that it compounded the advantage of reservation and could produce top grades in which general candidates are perpetually junior, raising questions about efficiency and fairness to individuals.

04Judicial interpretation

Its validity was upheld, with the Seventy-seventh, Eighty-first and Eighty-second Amendments, in M. Nagaraj v. Union of India (2006), subject to the State demonstrating backwardness, inadequacy of representation and administrative efficiency. Jarnail Singh (2018) modified the first condition. In B.K. Pavitra v. Union of India (2019) the Court upheld Karnataka's law granting consequential seniority.

Why it matters for UPSC

Candidates should place the amendment in the Indra Sawhney–M. Nagaraj sequence and explain the catch-up rule it overturned. It is a good example of the dialogue, or contest, between Parliament and the Supreme Court over the reach of article 16.

Sources