Answer framework · PSIR Paper I
Machiavelli on virtù and fortuna
““Fortune favours the brave.” In the light of this statement, discuss Machiavelli’s concepts of ‘virtue’ and ‘fortune’.”
The platform’s own guidance for planning an answer. It is not an official or model answer.
01What the question asks
'Discuss' asks for an explanation and an assessment of both concepts, with the statement as the lens. 'Fortune favours the brave' is a Latin proverb, not Machiavelli's own sentence, though the last chapters of The Prince come close to it; the answer has to show how far he agrees with it.
The first trap is translation. 'Virtue' here renders virtù, which is not Christian or moral goodness but the capacity to impose order on circumstance. The second is to accept the proverb without qualification: Machiavelli says that impetuosity usually does better than caution, but his deeper claim is that success comes to those whose way of acting suits the times and who prepare in advance. The third is to drift into a general essay on ends and means; the question is about two concepts and the relationship between them.
02The approach
Treat fortuna and virtù as a pair that defines the space of political action. Fortune is contingency: events no one controls, which in chapter 25 of The Prince govern perhaps half of human affairs and are compared to a river in flood. Virtù is the set of qualities that lets an actor master contingency: foresight, decisiveness, adaptability and, where necessary, ruthlessness. Fortune supplies the occasion; virtù decides what is made of it.
Build the answer from the texts. Chapter 6 gives the founders, chapter 7 Cesare Borgia, chapter 8 Agathocles and the limits of virtù, chapter 25 the river, Pope Julius II and the image of fortune as a woman. The Discourses add the republican answer: a city with many citizens of different temperaments can change its methods as the times change, which a single prince cannot. Close with the scholarly readings (Quentin Skinner and J. G. A. Pocock on republican virtù, Hanna Pitkin on gender) and a judgement on the proverb.
03Competing viewpoints
The activist reading: fortune yields to boldness
Machiavelli breaks with fatalism. Fortune is powerful but not sovereign: it shows its force where no virtù has prepared defences, as a flood does where no dykes were built. Chapter 25 holds that it is better to be impetuous than cautious, and pictures fortune as a woman who favours the young because they are bolder. Moses, Cyrus, Romulus and Theseus received from fortune nothing but the occasion; their virtù made it count. On this reading the proverb is Machiavelli's own conviction.
The prudential reading: virtù as adaptability and foresight
Boldness succeeds only when the times call for it. Julius II prospered by impetuosity because his times suited it, and Machiavelli remarks that he did not live long enough to meet times that demanded caution. Since people rarely change their nature, the temperament that brings success ruins them when circumstances change. Virtù is therefore flexibility of conduct and preparation in calm weather, the dykes built before the flood. Quentin Skinner reads it as whatever qualities a ruler needs to maintain his state and win glory.
The republican reading: collective virtù
In the Discourses Rome's greatness owes more to virtù than to fortune, and a republic outlasts a prince because it can change its leaders as the times change: the cautious Fabius Maximus when delay was needed, Scipio when attack was. J. G. A. Pocock reads virtù as the civic capacity of citizens in arms and well-ordered institutions to hold a republic steady in time. Gramsci's Modern Prince, the political party as a collective will, carries the idea into mass politics.
Critical readings
Pitkin's Fortune Is a Woman (1984) argues that Machiavelli's imagery ties political agency to an anxious, dominating masculinity: virtù derives from vir, man, and fortune is a woman to be beaten into submission. Alongside that fantasy of mastery she finds a more mature vision of politics among equal citizens. Leo Strauss read the separation of virtù from moral goodness as a teaching of evil; Isaiah Berlin answered that Machiavelli set a pagan civic morality against Christian ethics rather than discarding morality.
04Structure
- 1
Introduction
Identify the proverb as Latin and note that Machiavelli inherited the pairing of virtus and fortuna from Roman and humanist writing. Thesis: for Machiavelli fortune favours not simply the brave but those whose boldness is joined to foresight and suited to the times.
- 2
Fortuna
Contingency and its limits: half of human affairs (chapter 25); the river in flood and the dykes; fortune as occasion rather than fate. Contrast with a providential or fatalist view of history.
- 3
Virtù
Not moral virtue but energy, judgement, decisiveness and adaptability. The founders (chapter 6); Cesare Borgia, who rose by fortune, showed virtù and fell when fortune turned (chapter 7); Agathocles, whose crimes won power but not glory, which shows that virtù has a limit even for Machiavelli (chapter 8).
- 4
Testing the proverb
Chapter 25's preference for impetuosity and the image of fortune as a woman; Julius II; then the qualification that no one can change their nature, and the Discourses' answer that republics adapt better (Fabius and Scipio).
- 5
Interpretations and relevance
Skinner and Pocock on republican virtù; Pitkin on gender; Strauss and Berlin on morality. A brief present-day application: crisis leadership depends on capacity built before the crisis, such as health systems built before a pandemic.
- 6
Conclusion
The proverb is half Machiavelli's. Boldness helps, but durable success belongs to the prepared and the adaptable, and most reliably to free republics.
05Evidence and examples
- *The Prince*, chapter 25: fortune governs perhaps half of human affairs and is compared to a river in flood that dykes built in calm weather can contain.
- Moses, Cyrus, Romulus and Theseus (chapter 6): fortune gave them only the occasion; their *virtù* founded lasting orders.
- Cesare Borgia (chapter 7): rose through his father's fortune and built well, but was undone when his father died while he himself was gravely ill.
- Agathocles of Syracuse (chapter 8): won power by crime, yet Machiavelli denies that killing fellow citizens and betraying friends can be called *virtù*; such methods win rule but not glory.
- Pope Julius II (chapter 25): succeeded by impetuosity because the times suited it.
- Fabius Maximus and Scipio (*Discourses*, Book III, chapter 9): Rome could change commanders as the times changed.
- Crisis leadership today: what states could do in the COVID-19 pandemic depended heavily on health systems and institutions built before it, Machiavelli's dykes.
Counterarguments
Structural critics reply that the proverb exaggerates individual agency: class relations, the international system and economic cycles shape outcomes more than a leader's daring, so virtù explains less than Machiavelli supposed. Moral critics object that once virtù is separated from goodness, success becomes its own justification; the Agathocles passage shows Machiavelli himself uneasy about where the line falls.
Feminist critics see in the gendered imagery not a figure of speech but a theory of politics as domination. A balanced answer can grant all three while showing that Machiavelli's own qualifications, the limits of temperament and the advantages of republics, already concede much of the structural point.
Evaluation
The best reading treats Machiavelli neither as a simple voluntarist nor as a fatalist. He gives fortune half of human affairs and makes virtù the art of acting well within it, which is why preparation and adaptability matter more in his argument than courage alone. Chapter 25 supports the proverb rhetorically, but its own example, Julius II, shows that boldness succeeded because it matched the times.
The Discourses complete the argument: a political order lasts against fortune when its institutions and citizens supply a range of qualities no single ruler possesses. Skinner's flexible virtù and Pocock's civic virtù fit the texts best; Pitkin's critique exposes the cost of the imagery without overturning that conclusion.
Conclusion
Fortune favours the brave only when bravery suits the times. For Machiavelli it favours more reliably the prepared, the adaptable and the free city whose many citizens can do what no single prince can.
An illustrative answer
Show an illustrative answer written for this platform
Written to show the framework in use. It is one way to answer, not the answer, and it is not an official or model answer.
'Fortune favours the brave' is a Latin proverb, and Machiavelli inherited from Roman and humanist writers the contest between virtus and fortuna. He changed both terms. Fortune is contingency, not providence: in chapter 25 of The Prince it governs perhaps half of our actions and behaves like a river in flood, devastating where no dykes have been built. Virtù is not moral goodness but the capacity to master circumstance: foresight, decision, adaptability and, when necessary, ruthlessness.
The founders of chapter 6, Moses, Cyrus, Romulus and Theseus, received from fortune only the occasion; their virtù made it count. Cesare Borgia shows the reverse: he rose through his father's fortune, built well, and was undone when his father died while he himself lay ill. Agathocles marks a limit: power won by crime is not virtù, because it brings rule without glory.
Machiavelli seems to endorse the proverb when he says that impetuosity usually does better than caution and pictures fortune as a woman who favours the bold. But his example is Julius II, whose impetuosity succeeded because the times suited it. Since people rarely change their nature, the temperament that brings success brings ruin when the times change. The Discourses draw the conclusion: a republic, which can turn from the cautious Fabius to the bold Scipio, adapts where a prince cannot.
Interpreters divide. Skinner and Pocock read virtù as the civic capacity of a free people; Hanna Pitkin exposes the gendered fantasy of mastery in the imagery of fortune; Strauss saw a teacher of evil, Berlin a rival morality.
The proverb is half true for Machiavelli. Fortune yields to boldness that is prepared and suited to the times, and most reliably to free institutions, which supply the variety of virtù that no individual possesses.
Sources
- 01Niccolò Machiavelli, The Prince
- 02Niccolò Machiavelli, Discourses on Livy
- 03Quentin Skinner, Machiavelli: A Very Short Introduction
- 04J. G. A. Pocock, The Machiavellian Moment
- 05Hanna Fenichel Pitkin, Fortune Is a Woman: Gender and Politics in the Thought of Niccolò Machiavelli
- 06Isaiah Berlin, 'The Originality of Machiavelli'
- 07Harvey C. Mansfield, Machiavelli's Virtue