Landmark judgment · 1964
Sajjan Singh
The Court upheld the 17th Amendment and reaffirmed Shankari Prasad, but two judges' doubts about whether Parliament could alter the Constitution's basic features planted the seed of the basic structure doctrine.
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Decided
- 30 October 1964
- Bench
- 5-judge Constitution Bench
- Citation
- AIR 1965 SC 845
01The constitutional issue
The 17th Amendment (1964) widened the definition of "estate" in Article 31A and added forty-four land reform laws to the Ninth Schedule. The petitioners argued that the amendment curtailed the High Courts' jurisdiction under Article 226 and so needed ratification by the States, and asked the Court to reconsider Shankari Prasad.
02The decision
Gajendragadkar CJ, with Wanchoo and Raghubar Dayal JJ, upheld the amendment. "Amendment of this Constitution" in Article 368 covers every provision, including Part III, and an amendment is not "law" under Article 13. Its effect on Article 226 was incidental, so ratification was unnecessary. Shankari Prasad was rightly decided.
Hidayatullah and Mudholkar JJ agreed in the result but voiced doubts. Hidayatullah J questioned whether the Fundamental Rights were meant to be so easily altered by a special majority. Mudholkar J asked whether a change in the basic features of the Constitution could properly be called an amendment, or whether it would amount to rewriting the Constitution — drawing on a 1963 decision of the Supreme Court of Pakistan.
03Significance
The majority's reasoning lasted three years; the concurrences proved more durable. Mudholkar J's question — whether some features of a constitution lie beyond amendment — was taken up in Golaknath in absolute form and in Kesavananda in the form that endured. The case shows how a dissenting or doubting opinion can shape constitutional law long after the decision itself is forgotten.
04What happened afterwards
Golaknath (1967) overruled the majority view; Kesavananda (1973) adopted, in a refined form, the limit Mudholkar J had suggested.
Why it matters for UPSC
Prelims: 17th Amendment; Shankari Prasad affirmed; Mudholkar J's reference to basic features. In Mains, cite it when tracing the origins of the basic structure doctrine.
Explore further
Concept
PSIR Optional
Polity & Governance
Article
Sources
- 01Supreme Court of India, judgment of 30 October 1964. Supreme Court of India
- 02Sajjan Singh v. State of Rajasthan, AIR 1965 SC 845: text of the judgment (opens in a new tab). Indian Kanoon