Landmark judgment · 2011
Nandini Sundar (Salwa Judum case)
The Court held unconstitutional Chhattisgarh's use of poorly trained tribal youths as armed Special Police Officers against Maoist insurgents, and ordered the State to stop using them in counter-insurgency and the Union to stop funding them.
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Decided
- 5 July 2011
- Bench
- 2-judge bench
- Citation
- (2011) 7 SCC 547
01The constitutional issue
From 2005 the Salwa Judum, a State-backed movement in southern Chhattisgarh, mobilised tribal villagers against Maoist insurgents, and the State appointed thousands of young tribal men as Special Police Officers, armed but barely trained and paid a small honorarium. The sociologist Nandini Sundar, the historian Ramachandra Guha and others petitioned the Court, alleging killings, displacement and the conscription of youths into conflict.
02The decision
B. Sudershan Reddy J, with S.S. Nijjar J, held that deploying such youths in counter-insurgency violated Articles 14 and 21: it exposed them to grave risk, treated them very differently from regular forces doing the same work, and amounted to the State abdicating its duty to maintain order through properly trained forces.
Chhattisgarh was directed to stop using Special Police Officers against Maoists, recover their firearms, protect former officers and investigate crimes attributed to the Salwa Judum; the Union was told to stop funding such appointments. The judgment also sharply criticised development policies that, in the Court's view, had alienated tribal communities and fuelled the insurgency.
03Significance
The case asserted constitutional limits on how the State may fight an insurgency. The Union and the State objected that the Court had strayed into security and economic policy, and its broad criticism of development strategy was attacked as outside the judicial role. Its supporters regard it as a defence of the most vulnerable citizens in a conflict zone, where neither the State nor the insurgents respected their rights.
04What happened afterwards
Chhattisgarh responded with the Chhattisgarh Auxiliary Armed Police Force Act, 2011, absorbing many former Special Police Officers into a new force, which petitioners argued evaded the judgment. Contempt proceedings alleging non-compliance followed.
Why it matters for UPSC
Prelims: 2011; Salwa Judum; Special Police Officers. In Mains, use it on internal security and human rights, Left-wing extremism and governance in Fifth Schedule areas.
Explore further
PSIR Optional
Polity & Governance
Article
Sources
- 01Supreme Court of India, judgment of 5 July 2011. Supreme Court of India