Landmark judgment · 2023
Kaushal Kishor (Ministers' Speech case)
By four to one, the Court held that the grounds in Article 19(2) are exhaustive and cannot be supplemented to restrict ministers' speech, that a minister's statement is not attributable to the government merely through collective responsibility, and that Articles 19 and 21 can be enforced against private actors.
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Decided
- 3 January 2023
- Bench
- 5-judge Constitution Bench
- Doctrine
- Exhaustiveness of Article 19(2); horizontal application of Articles 19 and 21
01The constitutional issue
The reference arose after an Uttar Pradesh minister publicly described a 2016 gang rape on a highway near Bulandshahr as a political conspiracy. The Court framed five questions: whether restrictions on speech may be imposed beyond the grounds in Article 19(2); whether rights under Articles 19 and 21 can be claimed against persons other than the State; whether the State must protect those rights against private threats; whether a minister's statement can be attributed to the government; and whether such a statement can amount to a constitutional tort.
02The decision
V. Ramasubramanian J, for himself and Nazeer, Gavai and Bopanna JJ, held that the grounds in Article 19(2) are exhaustive: no further restrictions may be imposed, on ministers or anyone else, by invoking other rights. Rights under Articles 19 and 21 can be enforced against non-State actors, and the State has an affirmative duty to protect them. A minister's statement, even on a matter of State, cannot be attributed to the government vicariously by invoking collective responsibility. A statement inconsistent with citizens' rights is not by itself a constitutional tort, though it may become actionable if it leads officials to act or fail to act to someone's harm.
B.V. Nagarathna J agreed that Article 19(2) is exhaustive but dissented in part. A minister's statement made in an official capacity and reflecting the government's stand, she held, can be attributed to the government; she urged Parliament and political parties to regulate disparaging and hateful speech by public functionaries.
03Significance
The majority protected speech against open-ended restrictions while significantly extending the reach of Fundamental Rights to private actors. Its refusal to hold the government responsible for ministers' words was criticised as narrowing collective responsibility to a formality; its defenders saw a principled refusal to create speech restrictions without a law.
04What happened afterwards
In separate proceedings on hate speech since 2022, the Court has directed police in several States to register cases on their own motion, without waiting for complaints. The Law Commission's 267th Report (2017) had recommended specific offences of incitement to hatred.
Why it matters for UPSC
Prelims: 2023; 4:1; Article 19(2) exhaustive; horizontal rights. In Mains, use it on hate speech, ministerial responsibility and the limits of free speech regulation.
Explore further
PSIR Optional
Polity & Governance
Article
Judgment
Sources
- 01Supreme Court of India, judgment of 3 January 2023. Supreme Court of India
- 02Law Commission of India, 267th Report: Hate Speech, 2017
- 03Kaushal Kishor v. State of Uttar Pradesh, 3 January 2023: text of the judgment (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India