Constitutional body · Articles 315–323, Constitution of India
State Public Service Commission
The constitutional body in each State that recruits to the State's services and advises the State government on appointments, promotions and discipline.
01Composition
A Chairman and members, their number fixed by the Governor; at least half must have held government office for ten years (Article 316, Article 318). Two or more States may share a Joint State Public Service Commission, created by Parliament by law on resolutions of their legislatures (Article 315(2)); its members are appointed by the President. The Commission's expenses are charged on the State's Consolidated Fund.
02Appointment
The Governor appoints the Chairman and members, on the State government's advice. In State of Punjab v. Salil Sabhlok (2013) the Supreme Court quashed the appointment of a Chairman made without any process for assessing integrity and competence, holding that even where the Constitution prescribes no procedure, the State must act on relevant material and the courts may review the decision on limited grounds.
03Tenure
Six years or until the age of sixty-two, whichever is earlier. On leaving office, a Chairman may become Chairman or a member of the UPSC or Chairman of another State Commission, and a member may be appointed to those posts, but neither may take other government employment (Article 319).
04Removal
Although appointed by the Governor, members can be removed only by the President, on the grounds in Article 317: misbehaviour established by a Supreme Court inquiry, or insolvency, outside employment or infirmity. The Governor may suspend a member pending the inquiry. Removal is reserved to the President to protect members from the State government that appointed them.
Powers and functions
- Conducts examinations for appointment to the State's services (Article 320(1)).
- Advises the State government on methods of recruitment and on principles for appointments, promotions and transfers (Article 320(3)).
- Advises on disciplinary matters, legal costs and injury pensions of State government servants.
- Discharges additional functions conferred by State law, for instance recruitment for local authorities (Article 321).
- Reports annually to the Governor; the report is laid before the State Legislature with a memorandum on any advice not accepted (Article 323(2)).
Accountability
Accountability runs through the annual report to the Governor and the Legislature, judicial review of examinations and appointments, and the Right to Information Act. The Supreme Court's role in inquiries into misbehaviour gives members a degree of security against State governments, but also means that misconduct inquiries are slow.
Issues and debates
State Commissions have suffered far more than the UPSC from patronage and scandal. In 2002 the Chairman of the Punjab Public Service Commission was arrested in a cash-for-jobs scandal, and several other Commissions have faced allegations of manipulated recruitment. Question-paper leaks, cancelled examinations, prolonged recruitment cycles and litigation over answer keys and reservation have delayed appointments for years and fuelled protests by candidates.
The root cause is the appointment process: Commissions are often filled with political or bureaucratic loyalists, chosen without published criteria, and their independence from the government whose posts they fill is correspondingly weak.
Reforms
Salil Sabhlok (2013) pointed towards a transparent, criteria-based selection process. Several States have enacted laws against unfair means in recruitment examinations, and Parliament passed the Public Examinations (Prevention of Unfair Means) Act, 2024 for central recruitment bodies. Proposals include independent selection committees, statutory timelines for recruitment cycles and secure, technology-based examination systems.
Practice questions
- Q1UPSC Mains style15 marks· 250 words
Why have State Public Service Commissions been more vulnerable than the UPSC to scandal and delay? Suggest institutional reforms.
How to approach it
Appointment process, Salil Sabhlok, examination security, litigation, capacity; examples; selection committees and timelines.
- Q2UPSC Mains style10 marks· 150 words
Members of a State Public Service Commission are appointed by the Governor but removable only by the President. Explain the rationale.
How to approach it
Article 317; insulation from the State government; Supreme Court inquiry; costs of slow removal.
Practice questions are original to this platform and are not previous year questions. For questions actually set by UPSC, see PYQ Intelligence.