Skip to content

Answer Architecture Studio · UPSC CSE Mains

PSIR Paper I

Eleven steps, weighted to what Paper I of the PSIR Optional rewards: concepts defined and contested, and thinkers who do real work in the argument.

Three studios, one method

Model answers and guidance here are original teaching material. Nothing on this page is an official examiner’s assessment, and the studio does not mark answers.

Opening the studio…

Guidance · original teaching material

The eleven steps in PSIR Paper I

PSIR Paper I covers Political Theory and Indian Politics. Answers on it lean on thinkers and concepts. Here is the guidance the workspace gives at each step, in one place.

IRead the question

  1. 01

    Understand the question

    Read the question as a claim about ideas. If it is a quotation, a bare phrase or a proposition, say what it claims, and whose claim it is, before you decide what to do with it.

  2. 02

    Identify the command and analytical demand

    Identify what is to be done with the idea: explain it, test it, compare it, or judge how far it holds. “Comment” and “how far” ask for your judgement; “discuss” asks for more than one view.

  3. 03

    Map the syllabus

    Locate the unit of Paper I: Political Theory and Politics (Part A) or Indian Government and Politics (Part B). The unit tells you which thinkers and debates the examiner expects to see.

IITake a position

  1. 04

    Formulate the thesis

    Take a position on the idea: does the claim hold, for whom, and under which conception? A PSIR thesis is an argument about ideas, not a summary of them.

IIIBuild the case

  1. 05

    Identify the relevant concepts

    Define the central concept and show that it is contested: the conception you will use and the one you will question. Relate it to the neighbouring concepts the question touches.

  2. 06

    Select thinkers or theories

    Choose two or three thinkers who do real work in the argument: one whose position supports your thesis and one who challenges it. Use their arguments, not only their names.

  3. 07

    Build arguments

    Build the answer as a sequence of claims that moves the analysis forward: the concept, the strongest case for the claim, its limits, and what follows from them.

  4. 08

    Introduce evidence

    Evidence in Paper I is textual and illustrative: what a thinker argued (name the work only when you are sure of it), and an Indian or contemporary case that tests the theory.

IVTest it and conclude

  1. 09

    Consider counterarguments

    Bring in the rival school at its strongest: the Marxist, feminist, communitarian, libertarian or postcolonial critique, put as its best advocate would put it.

  2. 10

    Evaluate

    Adjudicate: which position survives the critique, how far, and why? This is what separates a PSIR answer from a summary of views.

  3. 11

    Form a reasoned conclusion

    Conclude in your own voice with a judgement that follows from the evaluation. Where it fits, connect the theory to Indian political thought or practice.

Word targets by marks

As printed in the verified official papers for PSIR Paper I, 2024–2026. The workspace sets each plan’s target from these figures.

  • 10 marks150 wordsPrinted on all 30 questions, 2024–2026.
  • 15 marksNo word limit printed36 questions, 2024–2026. This site suggests about 250 words.
  • 20 marksNo word limit printed18 questions, 2024–2026. This site suggests about 300 words.

Where no limit is printed, the length is a judgement about time and marks. Treat a suggestion as guidance, not a rule, and set your own target in the workspace if you prefer.

Where the questions come from

Official · 84 questions
Every question from the verified UPSC CSE Mains papers for PSIR Paper I, 2024–2026, exactly as printed and labelled with its year and number. Official papers: 2026 (opens in a new tab), 2025 (opens in a new tab), 2024 (opens in a new tab). Search them in PYQ Intelligence.
Original practice · 12 questions
Questions written for this site in the style of the paper, each with a teaching note on what it demands. None is a UPSC question.
Your own
Type any question, with its marks if you know them.