Skip to content

Answer framework · PSIR Paper II

Waves of criticism of the institutional approach

“Criticism of the institutional approach in comparative political analysis has come up in successive waves. Comment.”
UPSC CSE (Main) 2026 · PSIR Paper II · Question 1(a)Official paper (opens in a new tab)10 marksAbout 150 words

The platform’s own guidance for planning an answer. It is not an official or model answer.

01What the question asks

Directive. Comment asks for a reasoned view of the statement, not a catalogue of defects. The statement is itself a historical claim, so the answer must show the waves in sequence and say what each one changed.

Scope. The institutional approach in comparative politics: the study of constitutions, legislatures, executives, courts, bureaucracies and parties as the frame within which politics happens. The criticism runs from the behavioural revolt of the 1950s to the debates within, and about, the new institutionalism.

The trap. Treating the criticism as a single episode (behaviouralism), or as proof that the approach failed. The waves partly answered one another: each round of criticism produced a revised institutionalism, and the new institutionalism of the 1980s was itself a criticism of the behaviouralists who had criticised the old one. In 150 words there is room for three waves and a one-sentence judgement.

02The approach

Read successive waves as a dialectic. The traditional or 'old' institutionalism of James Bryce, Herman Finer and Carl Friedrich was formal-legal, historical and confined largely to Western Europe and North America.

The first wave of criticism came from the behavioural revolution of the 1950s and 1960s. Roy Macridis (1955) called traditional comparative government non-comparative, descriptive, parochial, static and monographic; David Easton and Gabriel Almond replaced institutions with systems, functions and political culture, so that the new states of Asia and Africa could be compared with the old. Decolonisation made the point sharply: constitutions modelled on Westminster or the French Fifth Republic described little of how power worked in many new states.

The second wave turned the criticism round. State-centred scholars (Bringing the State Back In, 1985) and James March and Johan Olsen (1984) argued that behaviouralism had reduced politics to individual choices and social forces, and that institutions shape preferences, identities and outcomes. The result was not a return to legalism but a new institutionalism, which Peter Hall and Rosemary Taylor (1996) divided into historical, rational choice and sociological variants; the sociological variant draws on Weber's account of bureaucratic rationalisation to explain why organisations come to resemble one another.

The third wave is criticism of the new institutionalism itself: that it explains stability better than change, neglects ideas and agency (Vivien Schmidt's discursive institutionalism), ignores informal rules (Gretchen Helmke and Steven Levitsky, 2004) and gendered norms (feminist institutionalism), and generalises from Western cases.

The judgement follows from the pattern: the approach has survived by absorbing its critics, and the live question is no longer whether institutions matter but which institutions, formal or informal, and how they change. See Comparative Politics: Nature and Approaches.

03Competing viewpoints

The behavioural critique

Traditional institutionalism studied what constitutions said rather than what political actors did. It was legalistic, descriptive and Eurocentric, and it had no way of comparing systems whose formal structures differed. Behaviouralists such as Easton, Almond and Robert Dahl wanted general, testable propositions about behaviour, culture and function; Dahl's essay of 1961 described the behavioural approach as a protest that had succeeded. On this view institutions are dependent variables, the residue of social forces and individual choices.

The new institutionalist reply

Institutions are not neutral containers. They distribute power, structure incentives, shape what actors want and lock in earlier choices. March and Olsen charged behaviouralism with reducing politics to society; Douglass North defined institutions as the rules of the game; historical institutionalists traced how decisions at critical junctures set countries on paths that are costly to leave. On this view the first wave was right about legalism and wrong about institutions.

The critics of the new institutionalism

The revived approach is said to be better at explaining persistence than change, to treat ideas as an afterthought, to stretch the word institution until it covers every norm and routine, and to read the world through North Atlantic cases. Discursive institutionalists bring back ideas and discourse; scholars of informal institutions show that unwritten rules, such as clientelism or the understandings inside a dominant party, can complement or subvert formal ones; feminist institutionalists show that rules which look neutral are often gendered.

04Structure

  1. 1

    Introduction (about 25 words)

    Define the institutional approach as the study of the formal rules and organisations of government, and state the thesis: criticism has come in three waves, and each produced a revised institutionalism rather than its abandonment.

  2. 2

    First wave: the behavioural revolt (about 40 words)

    Formal-legal, descriptive, parochial: Macridis's charges (1955). Easton's systems and Almond's functions as replacements; the new states of Asia and Africa as the cases that exposed the gap between constitution and practice.

  3. 3

    Second wave: institutions brought back (about 35 words)

    March and Olsen (1984) and Bringing the State Back In (1985) criticised behaviouralism's neglect of institutions; Hall and Taylor's three new institutionalisms (1996).

  4. 4

    Third wave: criticism of the new institutionalism (about 35 words)

    Change and path dependence; ideas and discourse (Schmidt); informal institutions (Helmke and Levitsky); gender; Western bias. One Indian illustration fits here: Rajni Kothari's 'Congress system' (1964) showed that the working of parliamentary institutions depended on bargaining inside a dominant party.

  5. 5

    Conclusion (about 15 words)

    The approach has survived by absorbing its critics; the debate now concerns which institutions matter and how they change.

05Evidence and examples

  • Roy Macridis, The Study of Comparative Government (1955): traditional comparative government was non-comparative, descriptive, parochial, static and monographic.
  • Robert Dahl, 'The Behavioral Approach in Political Science: Epitaph for a Monument to a Successful Protest', American Political Science Review (1961).
  • James March and Johan Olsen, 'The New Institutionalism: Organizational Factors in Political Life', American Political Science Review (1984).
  • Peter Evans, Dietrich Rueschemeyer and Theda Skocpol (eds), Bringing the State Back In (1985).
  • Peter Hall and Rosemary Taylor, 'Political Science and the Three New Institutionalisms', Political Studies (1996): historical, rational choice and sociological institutionalism.
  • Gretchen Helmke and Steven Levitsky, 'Informal Institutions and Comparative Politics: A Research Agenda', Perspectives on Politics (2004): informal rules may complement, accommodate, compete with or substitute for formal ones.
  • Vivien Schmidt, 'Discursive Institutionalism: The Explanatory Power of Ideas and Discourse', Annual Review of Political Science (2008).
  • Rajni Kothari, 'The Congress “System” in India', Asian Survey (1964).

Counterarguments

The image of waves can exaggerate the breaks. The best traditional scholars were not mere lawyers: Carl Friedrich theorised constitutionalism comparatively, and Bryce's Modern Democracies (1921) examined how institutions worked in practice. Behaviouralists did not abolish institutions either; Almond's structures and functions kept them in view under another name.

A second objection is that the new institutionalism won by stretching its central term. If an institution is any rule, norm or routine, institutional explanations become hard to falsify, the danger Giovanni Sartori called conceptual stretching. Rational choice scholars add that institutions are themselves equilibria chosen by actors, so that explaining behaviour by institutions risks circularity.

Evaluation

The strongest judgement is that the criticism has been productive. Each wave identified a real weakness (legalism and Eurocentrism, then the neglect of institutions, then the neglect of change, ideas and informal rules) and each was answered by a broader account of what institutions are and how they work.

The weakness that remains is the explanation of change, and here non-Western cases, in which formal and informal institutions diverge most visibly, now shape theory. India is a standing example: a constitution whose text owes much to the Government of India Act, 1935, operated through party systems, federal bargains and conventions that the text does not describe.

Conclusion

Turn the statement into a judgement: the successive waves have not discredited the institutional approach but repeatedly redefined it, from the study of formal constitutions to the study of the rules, formal and informal, that structure political life. Its resilience comes from its capacity to absorb its critics.

An illustrative answer

Show an illustrative answer written for this platform

Written to show the framework in use. It is one way to answer, not the answer, and it is not an official or model answer.

The institutional approach studies politics through the rules and organisations of government. Its critics have come in waves, and each wave has remade the approach rather than ended it.

The first was behavioural. Roy Macridis (1955) found traditional comparative government descriptive, parochial and legalistic, and Easton and Almond replaced constitutions with systems, functions and culture, which could be compared across new states where borrowed constitutions explained little.

The second wave criticised the critics. March and Olsen (1984) and the state-centred scholars argued that institutions shape preferences and outcomes, and a new institutionalism emerged in historical, rational choice and sociological forms.

The third wave targets that revival: it explains stability better than change, neglects ideas and informal rules, and generalises from Western cases. Kothari's 'Congress system' had already shown that India's parliamentary institutions worked through a dominant party's bargains.

The approach survives because it absorbs its critics; the debate is now about which institutions matter and how they change.

Sources

  1. 01Roy C. Macridis, The Study of Comparative Government, 1955
  2. 02James G. March and Johan P. Olsen, 'The New Institutionalism: Organizational Factors in Political Life', American Political Science Review, 1984
  3. 03Peter B. Evans, Dietrich Rueschemeyer and Theda Skocpol (eds), Bringing the State Back In, 1985
  4. 04Peter A. Hall and Rosemary C. R. Taylor, 'Political Science and the Three New Institutionalisms', Political Studies, 1996
  5. 05Gretchen Helmke and Steven Levitsky, 'Informal Institutions and Comparative Politics: A Research Agenda', Perspectives on Politics, 2004
  6. 06Vivien A. Schmidt, 'Discursive Institutionalism: The Explanatory Power of Ideas and Discourse', Annual Review of Political Science, 2008
  7. 07UPSC, Civil Services (Main) Examination 2026, Political Science and International Relations Paper II, question paper (opens in a new tab). Union Public Service Commission