Skip to content

International relations theory

Morton A. Kaplan

American pioneer of systems theory in international relations, who modelled six possible international systems and the rules each imposes on the actors within it.

Thinker dossier

1921–2017

Key works
System and Process in International Politics · 1957'Balance of Power, Bipolarity and Other Models of International Systems' · 1957'The New Great Debate: Traditionalism vs. Science in International Relations' · 1966
Key concepts
International system · Essential and transformation rules · Six models · Unit veto system

Start here:An introduction

1 min read

Morton Kaplan (1921–2017) was an American political scientist who taught at the University of Chicago from 1956 until 1991. He belonged to a generation that wanted to turn international relations from diplomatic history into a science, and he asked whether international politics could be studied as a system: a whole whose parts follow identifiable rules, rather than a sequence of unique events.

In System and Process in International Politics (1957) he described six possible international systems, from the classical European balance of power to the Cold War's loose bipolarity and a hypothetical world in which every state could destroy every other, and set out the rules each would need to stay stable. A student should care because Kaplan founded the systems approach that the PSIR syllabus names, supplied the vocabulary of loose and tight bipolarity used to describe the Cold War, and stood at the centre of the 1960s debate over whether international relations can be a science.

How to read this profile

The introduction is the first reading. The seventeen parts below are the full study of Morton A. Kaplan, in five movements, about 9 minutes in all. Parts marked Advanced analysis (5, 11 and 12) weigh and contest the arguments: read them once the rest is secure.

Parts 1–4

Movement I: Foundations

The thinker in time: the setting, the influences, the works and the principal arguments.

01Historical context

Kaplan belonged to the behavioural movement that sought to make international relations a science. Systems theory was spreading through the social sciences, from Talcott Parsons' sociology to David Easton's systems analysis of political life, and game theory was reshaping strategic thought in the nuclear age. The bipolar Cold War seemed to invite models of how systems of states behave.

Life and intellectual formation

Born on 9 May 1921, Kaplan served in the army during the Second World War, studied at Temple University and took his doctorate at Columbia. He joined the political science department of the University of Chicago in 1956, became a distinguished service professor and chaired its Committee on International Relations, and retired in 1991. He wrote widely on philosophy of science and on law and politics as well as on international systems. He died on 26 September 2017, aged 96.

02Intellectual influences

Kaplan's framework came from the general theory of systems that spread through the natural and social sciences after 1945. Ludwig von Bertalanffy's general systems theory and Norbert Wiener's cybernetics suggested that very different systems could be analysed with common concepts of equilibrium, feedback and regulation, and W. Ross Ashby's Design for a Brain (1952) supplied the idea of an ultrastable system, which adjusts its internal states to keep its essential variables within limits. Talcott Parsons's sociology of action systems and David Easton's systems analysis of political life showed how the approach could be applied to politics. The theory of games, from John von Neumann and Oskar Morgenstern (1944), shaped his treatment of strategy and coalitions, and the classical European balance of power, as described by diplomatic historians and by realists such as Hans Morgenthau, gave him the system he modelled first.

He reacted against the traditional study of international relations as diplomatic history, law and political philosophy, which he thought could not generate testable propositions, and against the idea that each international event is unique.

03Major works

  1. 1957System and Process in International Politics
  2. 1957'Balance of Power, Bipolarity and Other Models of International Systems'
  3. 1966'The New Great Debate: Traditionalism vs. Science in International Relations'His reply to Hedley Bull.
  4. 1969Macropolitics
  5. 1979Towards Professionalism in International Theory: Macrosystem AnalysisEssays setting out criteria for a 'professional' theory of international politics, including a reply to Waltz's critique of his systems approach.

04Principal arguments

Systems of action

Kaplan treated international politics as a system of action whose behaviour could be modelled by specifying a small set of variables: the essential rules that describe the behaviour necessary to keep the system in equilibrium, the transformation rules that describe how it changes when those rules are broken, the actor classificatory variables (national actors, blocs, universal organisations), the capability variables and the information variables. The aim was to state, for each type of system, the conditions of its stability and the direction of its change, and to make those statements comparable across history.

Six models

System and Process in International Politics set out six models: the balance of power system, the loose bipolar and tight bipolar systems, the universal system, the hierarchical system (directive or non-directive) and the unit veto system, in which every actor can destroy any other, as in a world of universal nuclear deterrence. Only the first two had clear historical counterparts; the others were hypothetical, ways of reasoning about possible futures.

The balance of power system

The balance of power system, which Kaplan associated with eighteenth- and nineteenth-century Europe, requires at least five essential national actors and six rules: increase capabilities but negotiate rather than fight; fight rather than pass up an opportunity to increase capabilities; stop fighting rather than eliminate an essential actor; oppose any coalition or actor that tends to predominate; constrain actors who subscribe to supranational organising principles; and permit defeated actors to re-enter the system as acceptable partners. The rules are interdependent, and when they are violated, for instance by an actor that seeks to eliminate others or by the rise of supranational ideologies, the system transforms. The model explains why the European balance tolerated limited wars but not the destruction of great powers, and why it broke down when revolutionary and national ideologies made actors unwilling to treat one another as acceptable partners.

Bipolarity and the universal actor

The post-1945 world approximated his loose bipolar system: two blocs led by superpowers, uncommitted national actors and a universal actor, the United Nations, mediating between them. Its stability depended on the blocs' rivalry being moderated by the uncommitted states and the universal organisation. A tight bipolar system, in which the uncommitted actors and the universal actor disappear, would be more rigid and dangerous. Kaplan also used game theory and, later, computer simulation to explore how actors would behave under each model.

The great debate

In 1966 Hedley Bull defended the 'classical approach' and attacked the scientific school, with Kaplan's work as a main target. Kaplan's reply, 'The New Great Debate', argued that the traditionalists confused the difficulty of rigorous theory with its impossibility, that their own judgements contained untested generalisations, and that models are heuristic tools for disciplined comparison rather than claims to have captured reality.

Parts 5–10

Movement II: Theory

What the thinker added to political theory, the concepts they defined, and their positions on the state, power, liberty, equality, justice and democracy.

05Major theoretical contributions

Advanced analysis

Kaplan's main contribution was to make the international system itself a unit of analysis. Drawing on general systems theory, he argued that international politics could be described by a small set of variables, essential rules, transformation rules, and the classification, capabilities and information of actors, and that different combinations define types of system with their own conditions of stability.

His six models, balance of power, loose bipolar, tight bipolar, universal, hierarchical and unit veto, gave the discipline a typology of international orders and a way of reasoning about possible futures as well as past ones. The six rules of the balance of power system made explicit the behaviour that keeps such a system stable and explained why it breaks down when actors refuse to treat one another as acceptable partners.

He introduced the distinction between loose and tight bipolarity, which gave uncommitted states and the United Nations a theoretical place in the Cold War order, and the unit veto system, an early model of a world of general nuclear deterrence.

Methodologically, he was a leading advocate of rigorous, model-based theory, using game theory and later simulation. His exchange with Hedley Bull in 1966 defined the debate between traditional and scientific approaches, often called the second great debate, and his work became both the starting point and the foil for Waltz's structural theory.

06Conceptual definitions

International system

A set of interacting actors whose behaviour follows identifiable rules, analysed as a whole rather than through individual states.

Essential and transformation rules

The behaviour required to keep a system in equilibrium, and the rules describing how it changes when that behaviour fails.

Six models

Balance of power, loose bipolar, tight bipolar, universal, hierarchical and unit veto systems, each with its own rules and conditions of stability.

Unit veto system

A hypothetical system in which every actor can destroy any other, anticipating debates about general nuclear proliferation.

07Theory of the State

National actors are one class of actor among several: blocs, bloc leaders and universal organisations also act within the system, and the balance between them defines its type. States behave according to the rules of the system in which they find themselves, whatever their domestic character. Yet his rules show that the outlook of actors matters at the margin. An actor that adopts a supranational or revolutionary ideology and refuses to treat others as acceptable partners violates the essential rules, and enough such violations transform the system, which is how Kaplan explained the breakdown of the classical European balance of power.

08Theory of Power

Capabilities are a variable of the system, and their distribution among essential actors, together with the rules actors follow, determines its stability. In the balance of power system the pursuit of capability is limited by the need to preserve the other essential actors. Kaplan did not ground power in human drives, as Morgenthau did; it is a resource whose pursuit the system's rules constrain. In bipolar systems power is organised in blocs, so the capability of the bloc leaders matters more than that of any member, and in the unit veto system, where every actor can destroy any other, capability no longer confers the usual advantage, since no actor can use it safely.

Parts 11–12

Movement III: Critique

How the arguments have been attacked, and how scholars read them differently.

11Criticisms

Advanced analysis

  1. 01

    Hedley Bull

    In 'International Theory: The Case for a Classical Approach' (1966) Bull argued that scientific models such as Kaplan's were abstract, untestable and of little use for understanding international society, which requires historical, legal and philosophical judgement.

  2. 02

    Kenneth Waltz

    Waltz called Kaplan's systems theory reductionist, because it defined systems by the behaviour and rules of their units rather than by structure, so that its 'system' was a description of what states do rather than an explanation of why.

  3. 03

    Stanley Hoffmann

    'International Relations: The Long Road to Theory' (1959) argued that Kaplan's models were too abstract and too detached from history, and proposed instead a historical sociology of international systems.

12Scholarly debates

Advanced analysis

How scholars have read Morton A. Kaplan differently. An answer that names the reading it follows is stronger than one that treats the text as settled.

  1. Failed science or heuristic modelling

    Critics such as Hoffmann (1959) and Bull (1966) judged Kaplan's work as an attempt at predictive science and found that it predicted little and could not be tested. Kaplan answered that the models were heuristic: they made assumptions explicit, generated hypotheses and organised comparison across historical systems. Richard Rosecrance's Action and Reaction in World Politics (1963), which compared nine historical European systems, shows the historical-comparative use to which the systems approach could be put.

  2. Forerunner of structural realism or its foil

    Waltz's Theory of International Politics (1979) treated Kaplan as the leading example of a systems theory that failed to be systemic, and built structural realism against him. Others read the relation as one of descent: Kaplan placed the system rather than the state at the centre of analysis, made polarity and the stability of bipolarity central questions and anticipated the nuclear debates in his unit veto model, all themes Waltz developed. His rules also resemble the shared practices that the English School calls institutions of international society, which suggests that the classical and scientific approaches were closer than the debate of 1966 implied.

Parts 13–15

Movement IV: Legacy

Why the thinker matters now, whom they connect with, and the arguments applied in India and beyond.

13Contemporary relevance

PSIR Paper II names systems theory among approaches to the study of international relations, and Kaplan is its founding figure. His models inform the vocabulary of bipolarity, non-alignment and the Cold War in the changing international order, and the method of asking what rules a system needs in order to remain stable is still useful for thinking about the transition from American unipolarity.

14Connections with other thinkers

Each connection recorded in this profile, by relation: who shaped Morton A. Kaplan, whom Morton A. Kaplan shaped, and who argued with or against them.

In contrast with

  • Hans J. Morgenthau1904

    Kaplan's scientific modelling contrasts with Morgenthau's historical and philosophical realism, though both took the balance of power as central.

  • Robert O. Keohane1941

    Both sought rigorous theory, but Kaplan modelled whole systems by their rules while Keohane explained cooperation through institutions within an anarchic system.

  • Immanuel Wallerstein1930

    Both analyse wholes rather than single states, but Wallerstein's world-system is a capitalist world-economy defined by a division of labour, while Kaplan's international system is a set of political actors defined by the rules they follow.

Criticised by

  • Kenneth N. Waltz1924

    Waltz's Theory of International Politics rejected Kaplan's approach as reductionist.

Compare side by side

The written comparisons that involve Morton A. Kaplan, and pairings to open in the Comparison Lab, chosen from the connections above.

15Indian and international applications

In India

In the loose bipolar system, non-aligned India was a leading uncommitted actor whose diplomacy at the UN and in the Non-Aligned Movement worked through the universal actor that Kaplan's model gave a mediating role.

In the world

Debates about whether the world is returning to bipolarity between the United States and China, or moving towards multipolarity, revive his question of how system type shapes stability. The unit veto model anticipates arguments about nuclear proliferation.

Parts 16–17

Movement V: Examination

Where the thinker sits in the syllabus, and what UPSC has asked.

16Exact syllabus mapping

  1. PSIR Optional

    Paper II · Part A · Comparative Politics and International Relations

    Approaches to the Study of International Relations

    Approaches to the Study of International Relations: Idealist, Realist, Marxist, Functionalist and Systems theory.

    Official wording · 6 official questions on this line in the PYQ dataset, 2024–26

    In the Syllabus NavigatorWhere it is taught
  2. PSIR Optional

    Paper II · Part A · Comparative Politics and International Relations

    Key Concepts in International Relations

    Key concepts in International Relations: National interest, security and power; Balance of power and deterrence; Transnational actors and collective security; World capitalist economy and globalisation.

    Official wording · 10 official questions on this line in the PYQ dataset, 2024–26

    In the Syllabus NavigatorWhere it is taught
  3. PSIR Optional

    Paper II · Part A · Comparative Politics and International Relations

    Changing International Political Order

    Changing International Political Order: (a) Rise of super powers; strategic and ideological Bipolarity, arms race and Cold War; Nuclear threat; (b) Non-aligned Movement: Aims and achievements. (c) Collapse of the Soviet Union; Unipolarity and American hegemony; relevance of non-alignment in the contemporary world.

    Official wording · 6 official questions on this line in the PYQ dataset, 2024–26

    In the Syllabus NavigatorWhere it is taught

The syllabus lines this profile of Morton A. Kaplan serves. Progress is kept on this device and gathered on your dashboard.

17Related PYQs (official wording)

No linked question yet

None of the questions in the PYQ dataset is linked to Morton A. Kaplan, so none is shown here. The practice questions further down are original to this platform, not previous year questions.

Dataset searched: Nine official papers, 228 questions: GS Paper II, PSIR Paper I, PSIR Paper II, 2024–2026.

Browse every question in PYQ Intelligence

Using Kaplan in an answer

Kaplan is the founding figure of systems theory, which Paper II names among the approaches to the study of International Relations, so he anchors any question on it. He also helps with the changing international order, where loose and tight bipolarity frame the Cold War and non-alignment.

Lead with his treatment of international politics as a system of action defined by essential rules, transformation rules and variables of actors, capabilities and information, and then with the six models: balance of power, loose bipolar, tight bipolar, universal, hierarchical and unit veto. The balance of power system, with its six rules and at least five essential actors, is the most examinable, because it explains why the European balance tolerated limited wars but broke down when ideologies made actors refuse to treat one another as acceptable partners. India's role as a leading uncommitted actor in the loose bipolar system gives an Indian application, and the unit veto model anticipates debates on nuclear proliferation. Contrast him with Waltz, who called his theory reductionist because it defined systems by the behaviour of units rather than by structure, and with the historical realism of Morgenthau.

Evaluate by weighing the classical critique of Bull and Hoffmann, that the models were abstract and predicted little, against the reading of them as heuristic tools for reasoning about possible futures, including a return to bipolarity. Avoid presenting all six models as historical descriptions, since only two had clear counterparts, and do not confuse his systems theory with the world-system of Wallerstein.

Practice questions (original)

  1. Q1PSIR style15 marks· 200 words

    Explain Morton Kaplan's models of the international system. How far does the loose bipolar model describe the Cold War?

    How to approach it

    Outline the six models and the balance of power rules; apply the loose bipolar model to blocs, non-aligned states and the UN.

  2. Q2PSIR style15 marks· 200 words

    What did the "traditionalism versus science" debate of the 1960s reveal about the study of international relations?

    How to approach it

    Present Bull's and Kaplan's positions; assess what each gained and lost; connect to later debates over theory and method.

  3. Q3PSIR style10 marks· 150 words

    Explain the six rules of Kaplan's balance of power system. What causes such a system to break down?

    How to approach it

    List and explain the rules; their interdependence; transformation through elimination of essential actors or supranational ideologies; the European case.

Practice questions are original to this platform and are not previous year questions. For questions actually set by UPSC, see PYQ Intelligence.

Explore further

Sources and further reading

  1. 01Morton A. Kaplan, System and Process in International Politics (1957)
  2. 02Hedley Bull, 'International Theory: The Case for a Classical Approach', World Politics (1966)
  3. 03Morton A. Kaplan, 'The New Great Debate: Traditionalism vs. Science in International Relations', World Politics (1966)
  4. 04Stanley Hoffmann, 'International Relations: The Long Road to Theory', World Politics (1959)
  5. 05Richard Rosecrance, Action and Reaction in World Politics (1963)
  6. 06Kenneth N. Waltz, Theory of International Politics (1979), chapter 3