Skip to content

Landmark judgment · 2024

Property Owners Association (Article 39(b) case)

A nine-judge bench held by majority that not every privately owned resource is a 'material resource of the community' under Article 39(b), rejecting the expansive view associated with Justice Krishna Iyer, and confirmed that Article 31C survives in its original form.

Property Owners Association v. State of Maharashtra
Court
Supreme Court of India
Decided
5 November 2024
Bench
9-judge Constitution Bench

01The constitutional issue

A 1986 amendment to the Maharashtra Housing and Area Development Act, 1976 allowed the acquisition of old, dilapidated "cessed" buildings in Mumbai for restoration, and claimed the protection of Article 31C as a law giving effect to Article 39(b), which directs that the ownership and control of the "material resources of the community" be distributed to serve the common good. Two questions followed: whether privately owned resources fall within Article 39(b), and whether Article 31C survives after Minerva Mills.

02The decision

Chandrachud CJ, for seven judges, held that Article 31C as upheld in Kesavananda survives: when Minerva Mills struck down the 42nd Amendment's substitution, the original provision revived.

On Article 39(b), the majority held that privately owned resources may in some cases be material resources of the community, but not every private resource qualifies merely because it meets a material need. The inquiry depends on the nature and characteristics of the resource, its effect on the community's well-being, its scarcity and the consequences of its concentration in private hands; the public trust doctrine may help. The view of Krishna Iyer J in State of Karnataka v. Ranganatha Reddy (1977), adopted in Sanjeev Coke (1983), that all private resources are included, reflected a particular economic doctrine that the Constitution does not prescribe, and was rejected. The validity of the Maharashtra law was left to a regular bench.

B.V. Nagarathna J concurred in part but objected to the criticism of Krishna Iyer J; Sudhanshu Dhulia J dissented, holding that the expansive reading remained good law.

03Significance

The judgment reads the Directive Principles as open to changing economic policy rather than tied to the socialism of the 1970s. Its critics see a narrowing of the State's redistributive mandate; its supporters see fidelity to a Constitution that, as the majority stressed, commits the State to the common good without fixing an economic model.

04What happened afterwards

The Maharashtra provisions were returned to a smaller bench for decision under the principles laid down.

Why it matters for UPSC

Prelims: 5 November 2024; nine judges; Article 39(b); Article 31C survives; Dhulia J's dissent. In Mains, use it on the Directive Principles, property and the economic ideology of the Constitution.

Explore further

Sources

  1. 01Supreme Court of India, judgment of 5 November 2024. Supreme Court of India
  2. 02Property Owners Association v. State of Maharashtra, 5 November 2024: text of the judgment (opens in a new tab). Supreme Court of India